Category: Family Law

PARENTING – Schooling – Where the parents seek that their children attend different schools The relevant authorities set out some of the applicable principles as follows: Schooling disputes are not resolved by the application of a “blanket presumption” or preference for the views held by the residential parent. The Court is required to apply the objects and principles of Part VII of the Family Law Act and to consider the statutory criteria in forming conclusions about the child’s best interests. Section...

Application for undefended proceedings [caption id="attachment_16383" align="alignright" width="350"] Application for undefended proceedings[/caption] The Court can make Orders where a party has been given an opportunity to participate in the proceedings but fails to do so. Principles The Family Law Rules provide mechanisms that allow the Court to determine a case if a party does not comply with the Rules, Family Law Regulations, or procedural orders. Family Law Rules 1.33 states: Failure to comply with a legislative provision or order (1)...

Legal Costs in family law proceedings: Overview and Legal Framework [caption id="attachment_16375" align="alignright" width="350"] Legal Costs in family law proceedings: Overview and Legal Framework[/caption] The law relating to costs in family law proceedings is well settled and set out in detail in the Full Court decision of Parke & The Estate of the Late A Parke. General Presumption and Exceptions An application for costs is governed by s 117 of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) (“the Act”). Section 117(1) of the Act sets out the...

Breaches of Financial Court Orders and Enforcement [caption id="attachment_14773" align="alignright" width="350"] Breaches of Financial Court Orders and Enforcement[/caption] Breaches of Financial Court Orders are common, though not ideal in Family Law matters, especially for property matters where large sums of money are to be paid and transfer of property is to be arranged. In general, financial orders require payment of a sum of money or the transfer of property/chattels. When a party refuses or fails to pay the sum or...

Property proceedings - Family Court of Australia - Full Court [caption id="attachment_11763" align="alignright" width="350"] Property proceedings - Family Court of Australia - Full Court[/caption] Barnell & Barnell [2020] FamCAFC 102  This case looked at the principles relevant to the assessment of contributions determining property proceedings pursuant to s 79 of the Family Law Act 1975 Applicable principles It is well-settled by the authority that the assessment of contributions under s 79 of the Act is not a mathematical exercise. Evaluating Disparate Contributions Contribution, either direct...

Understanding Defacto Relationships [caption id="attachment_16310" align="alignright" width="350"] Understanding defacto relationships[/caption] Section 4AA(1) of the Family Law Act sets out the principles that apply to defacto relationships. This Section mandates that regard must be had to all the relationship circumstances in determining whether it is one of a couple living together on a genuine domestic basis. Section 4AA(2) sets out some of the circumstances to be considered, including “whether a sexual relationship exists”, and Section 4AA(3) provides in effect that no particular...

INTERIM SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE The law – concepts and principles Section 74(1) of the Family Law Act empowers the Court to “make such order as it considers proper for the provision of maintenance” in accordance with Pt VIII of the Act. That primary requirement is set out in s 72(1) of the Act, as follows: (1) A party to a marriage is liable to maintain the other party, to the extent that the first-mentioned party is reasonably able to do so,...

CONSTRUCTIVE TRUST. Their Relevance in Family Law  A trust arises by operation of law where it would be unconscionable for a person who holds an asset to deny the beneficial interest of another person. Viewed in its modern context, the constructive trust can properly be described as a remedial interest which equity imposes regardless of actual or presumed agreement or intention (and subsequently protects) to preclude the retention or assertion of beneficial ownership of the property to the extent that...

Property issues in a de facto relationship Australia The Family Court of Australia has jurisdiction under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) (“the Act”) to determine matters relating to property as between parties who have not been married, where the parties have lived in a de facto relationship for a period of no less than two years and the relationship finally ended after 1 March 2009, the date on which the particular provisions of the Act commenced. The touchstone or foundational...

The Role of the Appellant Court in Family Law - Australia The High Court has reiterated many times that orders made in the exercise of judicial discretion under the Family Law Act as to the alteration of property interests can only be set aside on a strictly limited basis in accordance with the principles in House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499 (“House”) It is not enough that the judges composing the appellate court consider that, if they had been in the...

Consent Orders in Family Law Matters - Australia According to the information provided by Adam Cooper in a paper he has delivered.  Consent orders are a very useful means of obtaining orders from the Family Court in regard to property and children's matters. Consent orders carry many advantages, including the exemption in property matters for roll-over stamp duty and capital gains tax. Being an economical and less invasive means of resolution, an ability to divide superannuation interests between the parties,...

What is Evatt List? [caption id="attachment_15920" align="alignright" width="300"] The Evatt List – Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia[/caption] The Evatt List is an initiative in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia designed to triage and progress matters that are considered high-risk. The list aims to guide families that are going through a separation with high-level risks through the Court system at a much faster rate, given the urgency of their situation. Matters are eligible to be placed...

Beware of what you tell to the Judge The Court has the power to award costs for false statement against a party who deliberately misleads the Court  A vengeful spouse in Family Law Matters may seek revenge against a former partner by making a false statement and misleading allegations against his/her former partner, allegations that have no substance or truth.  Be careful what you say. Section 157 of the Domestic and Violence Protection Act (DFVPA) confers discretion to award costs...

We are heading into uncertain times The impact of the war in Ukraine and the affect on our economy The high cost of living Rising interest rates Inflation How is this affecting me? Am I able to financially care for my family?  How is this affecting my partner and my family's relationship? Is the stress too much to bear? Hopefully, there is a solution But what if it becomes too much and causes a breakdown in your relationship with your...

AFFECTS ON PARENTING OF CHILDREN On 26 March 2020, the Chief Justice of the Family Court issued a Statement on Parenting Orders and the affects of COVID-19. The Chief Justice’s statement provided guidance on the listing of matters in the Family Court. It was issued for the purpose of guidance in legal cases and was not a legal principle. It included the following: Parents are naturally deeply concerned about the safety of their children and how the COVID-19 virus will...

The law in regard to Binding Financial Agreement in Brisbane is extensive and complex. The law is governed by the provisions in the Family Law Act 1975 (as amended). Similar provisions are provided in the Act for de-facto relationships. Because it is a complex area of law it is a requirement (as detailed below) that the parties entering into a Binding Financial Agreement must consult a solicitor and obtain legal advice.  The relevant law is detailed as follows: LEGISLATIVE PATHWAY...

Can you use secret audio recordings in family law? As technology continues to evolve, it is becoming more common for clients to ask whether they can use secret audio recordings in their family law matters. Before you consider recording your conversation with the other party, there are several important factors that you need to consider, including: Whether the recording is legal to make in Queensland; Whether a Court will allow the recording to be used as evidence; and  Whether you...

A common question asked in Family Law is who is legally entitled to the matrimonial home during separation?  It is not as simple as one party kicking the other party out of the home. What be done if the property is in your name or What if the property is owned by both parties?  Property which is part of a Family law dispute has different rules to commercial and property law. Family Law the possession and ownership do not have...

Can I Take My Child Overseas Without Telling My Partner? Traveling with a child overseas is usually a decision for both parents to make, if they share parental responsibility for the child or if there are Court Orders in place.  Both parents are typically required to sign Passport Applications for their children. Parents should attempt to reach an agreement amicably about such travel decisions and consider attending family dispute resolution in the event that a disagreement arises.  Studies have shown...

Greater Support for Domestic and Family Violence Survivors in Queensland Queensland recently announced that a new pilot allowing the use of police body-worn camera footage in Court for domestic and family violence victim-survivors will be established under the Evidence and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2021. Essentially, video statements taken by trained police officers will be admissible as a survivor’s evidence-in-chief in criminal proceedings for a domestic violence offence, including breaches of domestic violence orders. The pilot stemmed from the recommendation...